Our Candies

Hooray! The person you send a Sugarwish to gets to choose from a selection of candies like these. (We always have over 80 yummy choices with seasonal favorites.) They get to pick their favorites to go into their Sugarwish gift box, which we ship right to their door. Sweet Happiness. Delivered!


Atomic Fire Balls (Individually Wrapped)

Jolly Ranchers

Lemon Heads (individually wrapped)

Strawberry Delights

Mini ½" Jawbreakers

Lemon Drops

Green Apple Drops

Watermelon Drops

Root Beer Barrels (Individually Wrapped)

Sugar-Free Root Beer Barrels (Individually Wrapped)


Banana Heads


Jaw Busters

Gummy Bears

Gummy Strawberries

Gummy Blue Raspberry Rings

Rainbow Sour Belts

Gummy Apple Rings

Gummy Butterflies

Gummy Peach Rings

Sliced Gummy Peaches

Gummy White Grapefruit

Sour Patch Kids

Swedish Fish

Sour Patch Watermelons

Gummy Pigs

Sour Cherry Colas

Sour Gummy Worms

Pink Lemonade Sour Belts

Strawberry Puffettes

Hot Tamales

Sugar-Free Assorted Salt Water Taffy

Caramel Creams


Mixed Salt Water Taffy

Birthday Cake Taffy

Chewy Sprees

Cherry Sours

Champagne Bubbles


Hot Cocoa Taffy

Sweet Peppermint Taffy

Fruit Tootsie Rolls



Sour Cherry Jelly Bellys

Bubble Gum Jelly Bellys

Coconut Jelly Bellys

Jelly Bellys (49 flavors)

Tangerine Jelly Bellys

Green Apple Jelly Bellys

Berry Blue Jelly Bellys

Reese's Pieces

Chocolate Covered Sunflower Seeds

Sugar-Free Milk Chocolate Covered Peanuts


Mini M&Ms

Peanut M&Ms

Mini Reese’s Pieces

Chocolate Rocks

Holland Mint Chocolates

Tootsie Rolls

Candy Cones

Boston Baked Beans

Bunny Corn

Surprise Me!

Good and Plenty

Licorice Bridge Mix

Jordan Almonds

Nik-L-Nip Wax Bottles


Peanut Butter and Jelly Mix

Trail Mix (unsalted)

Wasabi Peas

Dried Cranberries

Butter Toffee Peanuts

Cinnamon Peanuts

Sesame Peanuts

Corn Nuts